| Platinum | Garcia's Sandwich Shop |
| Gold | Drongkowskis' Farm Market & Deli |
| Silver | Fortinos Waterdown |
| Bronze | Mr. Sub |
| Top Pick | Jersey Mikes |
| Top Pick | Pita Pit |
| Top Pick | Sweet Paradise Waterdown |
| Top Pick | The Wandering Gourmet |
| Top Pick | Watermark Taphouse & Grille |